The Scenario
- Case type
- Personal injury (multi-vehicle collision)
- Side
- Plaintiff
- Production
- 50,287 pages from three defendants
- Time to trial
- 30 days
The Challenge: A Late Production on Top of Trial Prep
Thirty days before trial, the three defendants produce:
- 23,000 pages of medical records for the client and two other injured parties
- 15,000 pages of deposition transcripts
- 8,000 pages of police reports, accident reconstruction, and witness statements
- 4,287 pages of insurance documents and employment records
At 250 pages an hour, one read of 50,287 pages is about 200 reviewer-hours, five weeks for one full-time paralegal. The team also has about 105 hours of trial prep: experts, the trial brief, witness prep, and jury research. Whether or not it's deliberate, a production this size works like a discovery-overload tactic.
The hard part isn't reading speed. It's connecting a statement on one page with a record 20,000 pages later, which is hard for anyone after hours of review.
The Workflow in LexHound
The team uploads the production. OCR runs on scanned pages, processing runs in the background, and LexHound emails them when it's done. Then the attorney asks the case questions.
Question 1
“Who says what about the color of the traffic light? Cite every account.”
Defendant 1's driver: the light was green.
Source: Deposition of driver, p. 88, lines 4–11
Defendant 2's passenger: the light was yellow.
Source: Deposition of passenger, p. 41, lines 17–22
Police report: red-light camera shows red.
Source: Police report, p. 9
Three accounts of the same moment, ready for cross-examination.
Question 2
“Search the client's records for any back pain, injury, or treatment before the collision. List what you searched.”
No mention of back pain or back treatment in eight years of prior records. LexHound lists the 64 visits it searched.
Source: Visit index with a citation for each visit (prior records)
The attorney confirms the negative from the visit list, then gives it to the treating physician and the expert.
Question 3
“Build a chronology of the client's treatment from the collision to today, with billed amounts.”
ER visit 45 minutes after the collision
Source: ER record, p. 14,022
47 appointments across 9 providers, including 3 surgeries
Source: Chronology, each entry cited
Billed medical costs in the record total $487,000, against the defense's $290,000 figure
Source: Billing records, each bill cited
Total the bills from the cited entries yourself before relying on a number.
Question 4
“Compare the liability limits in each defendant's policy.”
Defendant 3 (a commercial carrier) holds a $5M policy; the other defendants hold $100K each.
Source: Declarations pages, pp. 47,102, 47,388, 47,611
What the Attorney Has Now
- Three conflicting accounts of the light, each cited to the page and line
- A cited negative on prior back injury, with the visits searched
- A cited treatment chronology and a bill-by-bill total
- The policy limits for each defendant
The team exports the findings to Word or PDF for the cross-examination outline and the pretrial brief. Each finding links to its source page, so the attorney checks it before using it.
Tips for Your Own Cases
1. Ask contradiction questions by topic
"Who says what about the light?" works better than "find contradictions". Name the fact and let LexHound gather every account.
2. Search for absences as well as mentions
Ask what isn't in the record, and ask LexHound to list what it searched so you can confirm the negative.
3. Check the totals
LexHound cites every bill. Total them from the cited entries before a number goes into a demand.