The Scenario
- Case type
- Medical malpractice (missed diagnosis)
- Side
- Plaintiff
- Expert materials
- 5 reports (142 pages), 5 depositions (847 pages)
- Key question
- Do the defense experts' opinions match their testimony and the record?
The Challenge: Two Well-Credentialed Defense Experts
A 42-year-old patient comes to the ER with a severe headache, is diagnosed with a tension headache, and is sent home. Three days later an undiagnosed aneurysm ruptures, leaving permanent disability. The defense relies on two experts:
- Defense Expert A (emergency medicine): the presentation “did not meet criteria for CT imaging,” so the ER care met the standard.
- Defense Expert B (neurology): even with a CT in the ER, the aneurysm was “too small to be detected”; only specialized angiography would have shown it.
The team has read every report and deposition, and has compared the defense experts with its own. What's easy to skip is checking each defense expert against their own testimony, and against the chart.
The Workflow in LexHound
A week before mediation, the team uploads both sides' expert reports, the five deposition transcripts, and the ER record. Then they ask three questions.
Question 1
“Does Defense Expert A's deposition agree with the expert's report on when a CT is indicated for headache?”
Report: "Headache presentation did not meet criteria for CT scan imaging."
Source: Expert A report, p. 6, ¶ 2
Deposition: "Standard protocol requires CT scan for severe headache with sudden onset."
Source: Expert A deposition, p. 118, lines 9–14
The report and the deposition state different criteria. The next question is which one fits the chart.
Question 2
“How did the ER record describe the onset and severity of the headache?”
Triage note: "Sudden onset, 10/10, 'worst headache of my life.'"
Source: ER triage note, p. 3
Physician note: "Abrupt onset while at work."
Source: ER physician note, p. 5
By Expert A's own deposition standard, the charted presentation called for a CT.
Question 3
“Compare Defense Expert B's opinion on CT detectability with what other experts said about imaging.”
Expert B: the aneurysm was too small to detect on CT before rupture.
Source: Expert B report, p. 8, ¶ 3
Expert A: the aneurysm was clearly visible on imaging three days later, after rupture.
Source: Expert A deposition, p. 121, lines 2–6
These statements aren't a direct contradiction: imaging after a rupture differs from imaging before it. LexHound puts them side by side; whether there's a real tension is a question for the plaintiff's neuroradiology expert.
What the Attorney Has Now
- A cited inconsistency between Defense Expert A's report and deposition
- The ER chart entries that meet the criterion Expert A gave at deposition
- A side-by-side of the imaging opinions, flagged for the plaintiff's expert to evaluate
These go into the mediation brief and the cross-examination outline. Each statement links to the page and line in its source, so the attorney checks it before using it.
Tips for Your Own Cases
1. Check experts against themselves
A report and a deposition months apart often state the standard differently. Ask LexHound to compare them on the specific point.
2. Check experts within the same side
Experts are retained and write separately. Ask LexHound to compare any two experts, on either side, on a named issue.
3. Bring the chart into the comparison
An expert's standard matters most when it's measured against what the record says. Ask for both in one answer.
4. Separate real contradictions from apparent ones
Statements about different times or conditions can look inconsistent without being so. LexHound cites both; your expert decides what they mean.