Skip to main content
Example Workflow

Answering a Pre-Existing-Condition Defense Across 73,000 Pages

How a plaintiff team uses LexHound to test the defense theory against 14 years of prior records and line up what each provider wrote on the day of surgery.

The Scenario

Case type
Medical malpractice (surgical error)
Side
Plaintiff
Documents
73,000 pages
Key question
Is there any record of nerve symptoms before surgery?

The Challenge: A Defense Built on the Patient's History

The client suffered permanent nerve damage in the left leg after back surgery. The defense expert says the damage came from a pre-existing condition. Answering that theory means reading the client's whole medical history, and the record is large:

  • 58,000 pages of medical records covering 14 years, from providers in four states
  • 12,000 pages of testimony from 31 depositions
  • 3,000 pages across 7 expert reports

At 250 pages an hour, one full read of 73,000 pages is about 290 reviewer-hours. A keyword search for “nerve damage” misses the other ways the same symptom gets charted: numbness, paresthesia, tingling, radiculopathy, neuropathy. With trial 30 days away, a second full read isn't realistic.

The Workflow in LexHound

The team uploads the full record. Processing runs in the background, and LexHound emails them when it's done. Then they ask three questions.

Question 1

“Find every reference to nerve symptoms in the left leg before the surgery date: numbness, tingling, paresthesia, radiculopathy, or neuropathy. List the visits you searched.”

  • No mention of nerve symptoms in the left leg in the pre-surgery records. LexHound lists the 212 visits it searched, from 2011 to the surgery date.

    Source: Visit index with a citation for each visit (pre-surgery records)

An absence is evidence for your expert, not proof. The visit list lets the attorney confirm the negative before relying on it.

Question 2

“Compare what the surgical, anesthesia, and nursing notes say about the patient's legs on the day of surgery.”

  • Operative note: "Procedure completed without complications." Procedure ended 2:02 PM.

    Source: Operative report, p. 31,408

  • Anesthesia note: patient states "I can't feel my leg" at 2:39 PM.

    Source: Anesthesia record, p. 31,592

  • Post-op nursing note: numbness in the left leg reported about 45 minutes after surgery.

    Source: Nursing note, p. 31,744

The first complaint falls within an hour of surgery. That supports causation for the experts to evaluate.

Question 3

“Build a timeline of every complaint about leg sensation after surgery, and when the surgeon was told.”

  • 2:39 PM: First complaint (anesthesia record)

    Source: Anesthesia record, p. 31,592

  • Surgeon notification: not documented in the post-op records

    Source: Post-op orders and progress notes, pp. 31,600–31,910

  • First imaging ordered 36 hours after surgery

    Source: Radiology order, p. 32,118

What the Attorney Has Now

  • A cited negative: 14 years of prior records with no documented left-leg nerve symptoms, plus the list of visits searched
  • A side-by-side of the operative, anesthesia, and nursing notes for the afternoon of surgery
  • A complaint timeline showing a 36-hour gap before imaging

All three go to the plaintiff's experts and into the demand letter. Each finding links to its source page, so the attorney checks it before using it.

Tips for Your Own Cases

1. Ask about concepts, not keywords

Graph RAG links symptoms, diagnoses, and synonyms, so one question covers what several keyword searches would miss.

2. Compare authors on the same hour

Surgeons, anesthesiologists, and nurses chart the same event differently. Ask LexHound to put their notes side by side, each cited.

3. Ask for the timeline of one symptom

Every mention, in order, each with its page. Gaps in response time stand out once they're on one list.

4. Late in a case, ask targeted questions

A second full read isn't realistic weeks before trial. Questions across the whole record are.

Try This on Your Own Record

14-day free trial with a signed BAA from day one. No credit card required. Your account is ready within 24 hours.