Skip to main content
Example Workflow

Birth Injury: Reconstructing the Labor Timeline

How a plaintiff team uses LexHound to turn 847 pages of labor, delivery, and NICU records into one cited, minute-by-minute timeline.

The Scenario

Case type
Birth injury (cerebral palsy)
Side
Plaintiff
Records
847 pages: labor and delivery, plus NICU
Key question
When did fetal distress begin, and when did staff respond?

The Challenge: Timing Decides Causation

A child is diagnosed with cerebral palsy at 18 months. The parents allege that delayed response to fetal distress during labor caused hypoxic brain injury. The hospital's position is that the injury was prenatal, pointing to maternal hypertension, a small-for-gestational-age infant, and no clear acute event during delivery.

The plaintiff's experts need a precise sequence: when the fetal heart rate changed, who saw it, when the physician was told, and how long the decision to deliver took. That sequence is spread across six kinds of records:

  • Fetal monitoring strips: 18 hours of tracing (278 pages)
  • Nursing notes: routine and as-needed entries (187 pages)
  • Labor room documentation: medications, vitals, interventions (154 pages)
  • NICU records: post-delivery care (118 pages)
  • Anesthesia records: epidural and C-section (67 pages)
  • Physician notes and orders: OB progress notes (43 pages)

Built by hand, this timeline means reading every page, logging every time-stamped event, and reconciling 24-hour times (14:23), 12-hour times (2:23 PM), and handwritten estimates (“around 2:30”). A paralegal can spend a week on it, and gaps only show up once everything is on one clock.

The Workflow in LexHound

The team uploads all 847 pages. Scanned strips and handwritten notes go through OCR, processing runs in the background, and LexHound emails the team when the record is ready. Then they ask questions.

Question 1

“Build a timeline of labor and delivery from admission to delivery. Put every entry on one clock and cite each one.”

  • 1:38 PM: Baseline fetal heart rate 140 bpm

    Source: Fetal monitoring strip, p. 187

  • 2:15 PM: Variable deceleration to 90 bpm noted

    Source: Nursing note, p. 412

  • 2:23 PM: Deceleration to 85 bpm lasting 45 seconds

    Source: Fetal monitoring strip, p. 189

  • 2:27 PM: Deceleration to 78 bpm lasting 90 seconds

    Source: Fetal monitoring strip, p. 189

  • 3:47 PM: OB first notified of fetal heart rate changes

    Source: Physician progress note, p. 667

  • 4:18 PM: Decision for emergency C-section

    Source: Physician orders, p. 671

  • 4:52 PM: Delivery; Apgar 3 at 1 minute, 5 at 5 minutes

    Source: Delivery summary, p. 689

The full timeline has 127 time-stamped events, each linked to its source page. These are the entries that matter for the notification question.

Question 2

“How long passed between the first deceleration and physician notification? Compare it with the notification policy we uploaded.”

  • 92 minutes passed between the first documented deceleration (2:15 PM) and physician notification (3:47 PM). Recurrent variable decelerations are a Category II pattern. The uploaded unit policy calls for notification within 15 minutes, which puts notification 77 minutes past the policy.

    Source: Nursing note, p. 412; physician progress note, p. 667; unit policy, §4.2

⚠️ Potential issue for expert review. Whether the delay breached the standard of care is a question for the nursing and obstetric experts.

Question 3

“List nursing documentation of fetal monitoring between 2:15 PM and 3:47 PM, and compare it with the expected 15-minute interval in the guidance we uploaded.”

  • Expected entries at 2:30, 2:45, 3:00, 3:15, 3:30, and 3:45 PM (six). Entries found: none.

    Source: Nursing notes, pp. 412–419; AWHONN guidance (uploaded), p. 6

LexHound compares charting with an interval when you ask it to, using the guidance or policy you provide.

What the Attorney Has Now

  • A cited timeline placing the first decelerations at 2:15 PM, during labor. That supports the plaintiff's causation theory for the experts to evaluate.
  • The notification gap: 92 minutes, each end cited, measured against the hospital's own policy.
  • The documentation check: six expected nursing entries, none found, with the pages searched.

Plaintiffs often argue that care not documented was care not given. Whether a jury may draw that inference depends on the jurisdiction and the testimony, but the attorney now has the cited facts to make the argument. Each entry links to its source page, so the attorney checks it before using it.

Tips for Your Own Cases

1. Put everything on one clock first

24-hour, 12-hour, and "around 2:30" entries hide gaps until they share a timeline. Ask LexHound to normalize the times and keep the original wording in the citation.

2. Upload the standard you're measuring against

Hospital policies, unit protocols, and professional guidance vary. Upload the ones that apply, and LexHound compares the record with them and cites both.

3. Ask about absences, not just events

Missing entries rarely show up in a keyword search. Ask what was expected in a window and what was actually charted.

4. Keep the conclusions for your experts

LexHound shows where to look and cites what it finds. Standard of care and causation are questions for your experts.

Build Your Next Timeline From the Whole Record

14-day free trial with a signed BAA from day one. No credit card required. Your account is ready within 24 hours.