Skip to main content
AI Tools and HIPAA

ChatGPT vs Claude vs Gemini for Legal Work

Which plans come with a BAA, and how to choose an AI tool for work involving medical records.

By Thomas Werner · Vendor terms verified

ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini all offer business associate agreements (BAAs), but only on specific business plans: ChatGPT Enterprise, Edu and Healthcare; Claude Enterprise and the Claude API; and Gemini through a Google Workspace account with Google's BAA. None of their consumer plans come with one (as of November 2026).

Which Plans Come With a BAA?

VendorProduct / planBAANotes and source
OpenAIChatGPT Free, Plus, Pro, BusinessNo BAAOpenAI does not offer a BAA for these plans. OpenAI: HIPAA eligible products
OpenAIChatGPT Enterprise, Edu, ChatGPT for HealthcareBAA availableThrough OpenAI sales; covers listed functionality only. OpenAI: HIPAA eligible products
OpenAIOpenAI APIBAA availableFor eligible endpoints; requested through OpenAI. OpenAI: BAA for the API
AnthropicClaude Free, Pro, Max, TeamNo BAAAnthropic does not offer a BAA for these plans. Anthropic: BAA products
AnthropicClaude Enterprise; Claude APIBAA availableEnterprise once HIPAA is enabled by the organization; API for eligible features. Anthropic: BAA products
GoogleGemini with a personal Google accountNo BAAConsumer accounts have no BAA. Gemini in Chrome is excluded even on Workspace. Google: HIPAA Included Functionality
GoogleGemini app and Gemini in Workspace (Google Workspace)BAA availableUnder the Workspace BAA an administrator accepts; some features may be blocked. Google: HIPAA Included Functionality
LexHoundEvery plan, including single seats and the 14-day free trialBAA availableSigned before any documents are uploaded; downloadable in the app. LexHound: HIPAA compliance
As of , from each vendor's published documentation. Vendor terms change; confirm the BAA for your specific plan before uploading PHI.

How to Choose an AI Tool for Legal Work

  1. The plan's terms: a BAA if PHI is involved, no training on your data, a stated retention period.
  2. Where data and models live: PHI should never leave the vendor's BAA-covered environment.
  3. Verifiability: can you check each answer against the source page, quickly?
  4. Fit for your documents: a general assistant, or a tool built to read whole case records?
  5. Who controls the accounts: firm-managed accounts, not personal ones.
  6. Cost per seat and whether the BAA requires an enterprise contract.

General Assistants vs Document-Analysis Tools

General assistants are good at drafting, summarizing and brainstorming. Analyzing a 20,000-page medical record is a different job: the tool has to read every page, connect events across documents, and show where each fact came from. That's what LexHound is built for. It uses frontier AI models inside LexHound's Google Cloud environment, Graph RAG across the whole record, and citations to the source page for every answer.

When HIPAA Applies to Your Firm

If your firm handles PHI for a covered entity, HIPAA requires a BAA with any vendor that touches it. Even when HIPAA doesn't apply directly, your duties of competence and confidentiality (ABA Model Rules 1.1 and 1.6) and protective orders call for the same safeguards. See our HIPAA checklist for law firms.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is best for legal work: ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini?

All three are capable general assistants. For legal work the deciding questions are usually the plan's terms (BAA, training, retention), whether answers can be verified against sources, and whether the tool is built for your documents.

Can lawyers use these tools with medical records?

Only on plans that come with a BAA (ChatGPT Enterprise, Edu or Healthcare; Claude Enterprise or the API; Gemini through a Workspace account with Google's BAA), and only within the features that BAA covers.

Do I still need to check AI output?

Yes. ABA Model Rule 1.1 and Formal Opinion 512 expect lawyers to understand the tool and verify its output. Tools that cite the source page make that faster.

Where does LexHound fit?

LexHound is a document-analysis tool for litigators rather than a general assistant: it reads the whole case record, cites every answer to the source page, and signs a BAA on every plan, including single seats and the free trial.

This page is educational content, not legal advice. Product names are trademarks of their owners; LexHound is not affiliated with these vendors.

Get a BAA on Every Plan, Including the Trial

LexHound signs a BAA with every customer, including single seats and the 14-day free trial, with no enterprise contract. Zero data egress; your data is never used for training.